"I have no fancy what fair happened here," Lopez, 41, told Toscano, who was in the base 3 with Stefano Langone and Jacob Lusk. "I’m shocked. I’m vexed. I don’t know what to mention."
PHOTOS: More ghastly Idol eliminations
NEWS: Idol stars express outrage over Toscano’s exit
Judge Jennifer Lopez fought behind tears behind Seacrest, 36, made the bulletin.
Future Oscar winner Jennifer Hudson achieved seventh during season 3, well behind contestants like Jasmine Trias and John Stevens. After strapping out Barry Manilow’s "Weekbring an end to … New England" — which Jackson phoned her best extravaganza as yet — Hudson was sent packing. Some fans reproved her exit in portion on a power outage in her Chicago hometown, while others, including Elton John Fake Juicy, plucked the race card. "The fact that [Hudson and companion "divas" LaToya London and Fantasia Barrino were] often in the bottom three — and I don’t want to set myself up here — but I detect it incredibly racist," John said.
While Idol fans persist to come to terms with Toscano’s early exit, differentiate Us: Which Idol elimination shocked you maximum?
Amid crowd boos, justice Randy Jackson prompted Idol fans namely "not an namely safe; you’ve got to poll as the ones you love."
VIDEO: Watch Pia sing “I’ll Stand By You”
Season 10 frontrunner Pia Toscano, 22, was voted off after having not emerged in the bottom three prior to Thursday’s disposal.
Though Toscano’s early exit came for a shock to fans, anyone dedicated Idol watcher knows she isn’t the premier contestant to quit also soon.
When American Idol’s Ryan Seacrest announced by the top of Thursday’s results show that the elimination would be a shocker, he wasn’t kidding.
By Allison Corneau for UsMagazine.com. For extra Channel Surfing, press here.
Case in point: Season 5’s Chris Daughtry, who fell martyr to voter apathy when fans failed to turntable and text for they thought he was a lock for the terminal two. The presumptive victor got the boot before runner-up Katharine McPhee and champion Taylor Hicks.